Conservative Index Add
pagetitle

Sunday, December 16th, 2018Last Update: Tuesday, October 30th, 2018 07:58:08 PM

Oklahomas Budget Hole Could Be $1 Billion Deeper

By: Brandon Dutcher

Oklahoma's budget crunch has been much in the news lately. But imagine how much worse the situation could be.

"Oklahoma has about 692,000 students in public schools," says Shawn Hime, executive director of the Oklahoma State School Boards Association. "According to the U.S. Census and data from the National Center for Education Statistics, more than 100,000 students are educated outside of the public school system."

Imagine if 100,000 new students showed up at their local public school tomorrow morning ("I'm here for my free education, please!"). If our elected officials wanted to keep per-pupil spending at its current level, they would have to come up with another billion dollars annually, based on numbers from the Oklahoma Cost Accounting System.

One of our policymakers' chief priorities is public education, i.e., making sure we have an educated public. Fortunately, it doesn't matter where that education takes place.

Some of it takes place in public schools, for which our political leaders are spending some $10,000 per student (according to the Oklahoma State Department of Education's own numbers).

Some of it takes place outside of the public school system -- in home schools, for example, or in accredited private schools, where the median tuition is $5,310, according to the Oklahoma Private School Accreditation Commission. Cash-squeezed appropriators should be grateful for these thousands of parents who are picking up the tab themselves.

Indeed, politicians should try to save even more money (and reduce school overcrowding) by redirecting some of those 692,000 students into the nonpublic sector.

Many parents would jump at the chance. In the last two years, three different scientific surveys have asked Oklahomans what type of school they would prefer for their children. Each time, many respondents (48 percent, 50 percent, and 30 percent) said they would choose a nonpublic alternative.

Policymakers should try to bridge the gap between actual enrollment and what parents want. A $5,000 voucher, tax credit, or education savings account, for example -- even if it didn't cover the full tuition amount -- would spur some of those 692,000 to choose alternatives outside of the public school system. (As for the 100,000 already outside the system? Sorry, I'm afraid in this budget climate that would be too tall an order.)

Redirecting some of those 692,000 students would have a positive fiscal impact on the public school system, but that's a subject for another day. What's important here is that it would have a positive fiscal impact on taxpayers and their elected leaders -- leaders who are trying each year to build roads and bridges, fund mental health programs, incarcerate criminals, increase teacher pay, and much more.

This positive impact on taxpayers -- now paying $5K instead of $10K, in my example above -- is obvious enough. We already see the principle at work with Oklahoma's higher education vouchers.

For example, the Oklahoma Tuition Equalization Grant -- which is nearly identical in structure to Oklahoma's private-school voucher program in common education (the Lindsey Nicole Henry Scholarship) -- is a modest $2,000 grant for students enrolling in private colleges. Created with strong bipartisan support in 2003, the grant has saved taxpayers more than $50 million, according to Oklahoma Independent Colleges and Universities.

Dr. Greg Forster, author of a research synthesis of the school-choice literature, says that out of 28 empirical studies, 25 find that school choice saves money for taxpayers and three are neutral. No empirical study has ever found that school choice has a negative fiscal effect on taxpayers.

In sum, policymakers staring at Oklahoma's budget hole should (1) thank the parents of 100,000 students that the hole's not a lot deeper, and (2) try to entice some of the parents of 692,000 students to help fill that hole.

Brandon Dutcher is OCPA's Senior Vice President His award-winning articles have appeared in Investor's Business Daily, World magazine, Forbes.com, Mises.org, The Oklahoman, the Tulsa World, and 200 newspapers throughout Oklahoma and the U.S. He can be contacted at: Brandon@ocpathink.org

About Brandon Dutcher

Dutcher is Senior Vice President at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs (OCPA) http://www.ocpathink.org/, which was founded in 1993 as a public policy research organization focused primarily on state-level issues. His award-winning articles have appeared in 200 newspapers throughout Oklahoma and the U.S. He can be contacted at: Brandon@ocpathink.org, at: twitter.com/brandondutcher or facebook.com/brandondutcher

Other Articles By Brandon Dutcher

What Type of School Would Oklahomans Select?

Leaders in the public-education community often point out (correctly) that the vast majority of...

New OU President Gallogly: We will not have waste on campus.

James Gallogly has been selected as the next president of the University of Oklahoma. Oklahoma...

The Higher Ed Defunding Thats Yet to Come?

Theres been much hand-wringing lately among some higher-education officials and journalists (to...

Bartlesville School Board Looks Out for Taxpayers

In June, the Bartlesville school board voted unanimously to outsource the schools janitorial...

Oklahomans Say Teachers Should Be Allowed to Vote on Unions

Getting public policy right in the area of education includes respecting teachers and freeing...

Nearly 4 in 10 Oklahoma Teachers Would Choose Private or Home Schooling for Their Own Children

When asked whats the best educational choice for their own children, one might expect near...

Oklahomans (still) Support Parental Choice in Education

An honest reading of the public-opinion survey data over the past couple of years shows that...

Other Constitution Columnists

Andrew K. Boyle

Meekness in Exchange for the Exhausting Burden of Winning.
Politics is a strange pursuit. Granted, self government is one of the highest and most burdensome...

David Deming

Conservative Christians Unwelcome at OU
The nation was transfixed by the smear campaign launched against judge Brett Kavanaugh. In a...

John Michener

Pharaoh, Pro-Life Politician
When should we abolish abortion, now or later? Pro-life politicians tell us we must support...

Richard Engle

Schoolyard Bullies Want Your Lunch Money
In the recent GOP primaries and runoffs we heard much about teachers, apples, school kids and all...

Tim Bakamjian

Stitt vs. Edmondson: A Comparison of Candidates
Oklahomas two main gubernatorial candidates are sharply different in background and approach to...

Charlie Meadows

YES on State Questions 793, 794 and NO on 798, 800 and 801
Here is my evaluation of the five State Questions that will be on the November 6 General Election...

Theodore King

THE FEDERAL PAGE for Fall 2018
November 2nd Feast Day of All Souls,Happy Birthday to Paddy Joe and My DadHappy 80th birthday to...

Steve Byas

Teacher Certification
The teacher strike of last spring has brought the issue of public education to the forefront in...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Congressional Seats Up for Election
The U.S. Congress is composed of two chambers. Senators serve six-year terms with only a third of...

Constitution Staff

Races for Statewide Secondary Offices
In addition to the governors office, a host of secondary statewide offices, and one seat for the...

Constitution Staff

The Race for Governor
Mary Fallin was prohibited by term-limits from seeking a third four-year term in 2018. With the seat...

Constitution Staff

Five State Questions on Ballot
Voters will find five state questions on the November ballot. Measures can reach the ballot by...

Constitution Staff

Record State Budget Projected
The next Oklahoma Legislature will have a record number of new members. This is a result of term...

Constitution Columnists

Andrew K. Boyle

Meekness in Exchange for the Exhausting Burden of Winning.
Politics is a strange pursuit. Granted, self government is one of the highest and most burdensome...

David Deming

Conservative Christians Unwelcome at OU
The nation was transfixed by the smear campaign launched against judge Brett Kavanaugh. In a...

John Michener

Pharaoh, Pro-Life Politician
When should we abolish abortion, now or later? Pro-life politicians tell us we must support...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing okconsti@aol.com
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.