Conservative Index Add

Sunday, July 5th, 2020Last Update: Thursday, June 25th, 2020 07:51:39 AM

Oklahomas Dismal Public Education Ranking

By: Byron Schlomach

Governor Stitt has made it his goal to move Oklahoma toward top ten status among the states. Exactly how he would measure this is unclear, but education is obviously targeted, given its prominence in his inaugural speech. This much is clear, though; Oklahoma will not become a top-ten state in education just by spending more money.

The truth is, rankings of state public education systems are inconsistent. WalletHub ranks Oklahoma 33rd, ahead of braggadocios Texas at 36th, and well behind our highest-ranked neighbor, Colorado, at 10th. Other rankings put Oklahoma solidly in the bottom ten of states. U.S. News ranks us 42nd; USA Today, 45th; and Education Week, 47th. These three rankings place Texas significantly above us, and our highest-ranked neighbors are variously Colorado and Kansas. The region most represented in the top ten is the northeast.

These rankings are complicated, taking account of ACT and SAT results that are not easily compared from state to state, in addition to a plethora of other arbitrary factors. WalletHub’s ranking, for example, emphasizes school safety, where Oklahoma does well. All consider higher spending the same as higher quality, but there are too many examples to list that show this not to be true.

A new ranking put together by scholars at the University of Texas at Dallas and published by CATO takes a simpler and more rational approach to state rankings, by ranking quality and efficiency separately. They use National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) results, the nation’s gold standard in academic performance measurement. They also account for demography, recognizing that for various cultural reasons, students of different ethnicities, on average, perform differently on the NAEP.

It turns out Texas actually does a better job of educating students of various ethnicities than most northeastern states with less diverse populations, so much so that Texas ranks 6th in the quality ranking. Washington, DC ranks 5th, because that district does a relatively good job educating its particular population, compared to most. Oklahoma ranks a low 41st in educational quality, outranking only Arkansas when compared to our nearby neighbors.

An efficiency ranking does not view higher spending positively. Greater efficiency comes from getting the most out of resources, so given Oklahoma’s spending level, often considered low, surely we are relatively efficient. In fact, with our higher efficiency ranking at 26th, of our nearby neighbors, only Texas (2nd) and Colorado (9th) rank higher. But, California and high-spending Washington, DC are also more efficient than us because cost of living is taken into account, and Oklahoma is not really a low spender when cost of living is considered.

Spending more on public education, and nothing else, as many in our legislature have promised, is guaranteed to make Oklahoma’s public education system even less efficient. In fact, the UT-Dallas study overstates our efficiency ranking because last year’s big spending increase is not included.

Thus far, the public education establishment has only promised the same methods with more money, making the definition of insanity – doing the same thing while expecting different results – particularly relevant. What we need are new, proven ideas that hold some hope that Oklahoma will improve educationally in both quality and efficiency, not the usual new gimmicks with big price tags. The Tulsa schools’ recent innovations using current resources, emphasizing career training and openness to nontraditional approaches, offer some hope. It is this hope for real improvement that drives so many who advocate for school choice, a proven way to improve educational outcomes. And how about this. Just expecting better work – from everybody – doesn’t cost a dime.

Byron Schlomach is Director of Oklahoma’s 1889 Institute ( The 1889 Institute analyzes and develops state public policy for Oklahoma based on principles of limited and responsible government, free enterprise, and a robust civil society. In addition to being Director at the 1889 Institute, Byron is also Scholar-in-Residence at the Institute for the Study of Free Enterprise at Oklahoma State University. Doctor Schlomach has researched and written broadly in public policy in areas as diverse as economic development, transportation, public education, welfare, health care, government finance and transparency, regulation, and occupational licensing. He has been published in numerous newspapers in Texas, Arizona, and Oklahoma as well as Business Week Online, National Review Online, and The Hill. Byron has made many media appearances on radio and TV during his 24-year career working in state public policy.

Other Stories From Spring 2019 Issue

2020 Oklahoma Conservative Index

Constitution Staff
The Oklahoma Constitution presents the 42nd annual Oklahoma Conservative Index rating our state...

Tidbits for Spring 2019

Constitution Staff
Democrats Select Wisconsin for ConventionIn March, Democrats selected Milwaukee to host their 2...

Letters to the Editor for Spring 2019

Constitution Staff
PET RATTLESNAKESIf there is one truth in life it is the fact that you cannot make a pet out of a...

No More Mr. GOP

Richard Engle
Many years ago when I was still young enough to be a Young Republican, I served as State Chair of...

The Duty to Abolish Abortion: We are Without Excuse

John Michener
The movement to abolish abortion has finally reached critical mass. Enough concerned and educated...

Stitts Strong Start

Tim Bakamjian
In his January 14th inaugural address, Governor Kevin Stitt outlined a clear set of goals for his...

The Expanding Role of K-12 Public Schools

Linda Murphy
The expanding role of social services and social change in K-12 schools should be closely examined....

Oklahomas Dismal Public Education Ranking

Byron Schlomach
Governor Stitt has made it his goal to move Oklahoma toward top ten status among the states. Exactly...

The True Meaning of the Constitutions Cruel & Unusual Punishment Clause

Bill Graves
1. The Framers Meaning of Cruel and Unusual PunishmentThe Constitutions Eighth Amendment p...

The Federal Page for Spring 2019

Theodore King
National Debt Now Exceeds 22 TrillionOn February 12, the United States Treasury Department repor...

Is the University of Oklahoma a Racist Institution?

David Deming
The University of Oklahoma is apparently becoming infamous as a hotbed of racism. In 2015, a video...

Conversion Therapy Bill is Totalitarian

Steve Byas
When it comes to abortion, the relationship between the physician (i.e. the abortionist) and...

Compact to Stop Corporate Handouts

Constitution Staff
Government support for businesses through subsidies and other special treatment, commonly referred...

State General Revenue Fund Collections above Estimate

Constitution Staff
State General Revenue Fund (GRF) collections in March were $508.9 million and came in at $31.8...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Oklahoma Presidential Primary Election
Oklahoma was among14 states holding Presidential Primary Elections on March 3, 2020 in what is known...

Constitution Staff

Statewide Races and Congressional Seats on Ballot
In 2020, the Oklahoma candidate filing period was April 8-10. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, ...

Constitution Staff

Republicans Will Retain Control of Legislature
The candidate filing period for the Oklahoma Legislature this year was April 8-10. Due to the COVID...

Constitution Staff

Legislature Considers Bills
The Oklahoma Legislature went into its annual mid-session recess on March 18, which coincides with...

Constitution Staff

Oklahoma Legislators Rated
The Oklahoma Constitution presents the 42nd annual Oklahoma Conservative Index rating our state...

Constitution Columnists

Ron McWhirter

Covid-19 Impacts the 2020 Oklahoma Conservative Index
We believe the most important product of this publication is our annual Oklahoma Conservative Index...

Steve Byas

Jim Inhofe
Perhaps another person could take his place and do an even better job than Jim Inhofe, but I...

Linda Murphy

Oklahoma Education, Covid and Global Control
Since Spring Break, the public schools have been closed due to COVID 19, bringing children and their...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.