Conservative Index Add

Saturday, June 6th, 2020Last Update: Wednesday, May 6th, 2020 02:21:47 PM

Attempt to Block Constitutional Gun Carry Fails

By: Constitution Staff

An attempt by an Oklahoma Democrat legislator, allied with anti-gun groups, to delay the constitutional carry of firearms from going into effect in Oklahoma came up short. But, after failing to obtain enough signatures to call for a statewide vote to block the law from going into effect on November 1, Rep. Jason Lowe (D-Oklahoma City) filed a lawsuit opposing the law in Oklahoma County District Court on October 7. He is suing Governor Kevin Stitt in his capacity as governor for signing the bill and asked the judge to prevent the law from going into effect until the case is heard.

In his lawsuit, Lowe contends the law is unconstitutional because it violates the state’s “single subject rule,” which requires bills passed by the Legislature to only address one subject. However, when asked to explain how House Bill 2597 violates that constitutional requirement, Lowe was unable to give an answer.

The legislation by Rep. Jon Echols (R-Oklahoma City) and Sen. Kim David (R-Porter), passed the Oklahoma House 70-30 on February 13, and the Senate 40-6 on February 27. Gov. Stitt signed the bill within hours of its final passage. It was the first bill signed by the new governor. “Oklahomans are strong supporters of the Second Amendment, and they made their voice known as I traveled across all 77 counties last year,” said Stitt. The bill essentially restores what the state of law was in 1789, when the U.S. Constitution was ratified, and the modern United States came into existence.

The legislation allows the concealed or unconcealed carry of firearms by any person who is at least twenty-one years of age, or at least eighteen years of age and in the military, if the person is not otherwise disqualified from purchasing a firearm. Under the bill, you cannot carry a concealed or unconcealed handgun in public and private schools K-college, public or private sports arenas, gambling facilities, government buildings, or into private businesses, unless allowed by the owner. The bill maintains current law in that you must pass a background check to purchase a gun, that you must disclose guns in your possession when requested by a law enforcement officer, and that those convicted of a felony cannot own or buy a gun. Gun owners can still obtain a license in Oklahoma, with reciprocity recognized in multiple states across the nation.

On November 1, Oklahoma became the 16th state to allow constitutional carry. Oklahoma joins Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Idaho, Kansas, Maine, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, North Dakota, South Dakota, West Virginia, Wyoming, and Vermont that allow the Second Amendment as an individual’s carry permit. The citizens of the 15 states where constitutional carry is allowed can carry without a permit in Oklahoma.

The legislation was one of the ten bills included on the 2019 Oklahoma Conservative Index rating state legislators. Representative Lowe scored 3 percent conservative in this year’s ratings, and has a 20% cumulative average for the whole time he has been in the Legislature.

On August 12, Representative Lowe filed a veto referendum petition. According to Oklahoma law, a veto referendum to repeal an approved bill can be filed within 90 days of the adjournment of the Legislature. The Legislature adjourned on May 24. Referendum Petition 26, was filed with the Secretary of State to place State Question 803 on the ballot. Lowe needed to collect and submit a minimum of 59,320 valid signatures on petitions by August 29.

Rep. Lowe worked with the Oklahoma Chapter of the anti-gun group Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America, and Young Democrats of America in the signature gathering effort. Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America is a gun control advocacy group created under a larger umbrella group formed with $50 million from billionaire Michael Bloomberg, the former mayor of New York City. Oklahoma City Mayor David Holt also publically promoted the petition. Holt is a former Republican member of the Oklahoma Senate. Holt had a 54% cumulative average on the Oklahoma Conservative Index.

Lowe and his allies delivered petitions on August 29 claiming to have close to the number of signatures required. Meanwhile, the Oklahoma Second Amendment Association (OK2A), 36 Republican legislators, and other groups of conservatives, aided by attorneys Kevin Calvey and Robert Robles, filed a brief with the Oklahoma Supreme Court challenging the petition. They said that the petition “set forth blatantly false, misleading, and deceitful and inflammatory statements in order to deceive voters into signing.” they asked the court to invalidate the petition because the signatures therefore would not be valid. “They’re all invalid as far as we are concerned. That’s why we filed the protest. Because of the misrepresentation of gathering those signatures to begin with,” said OK2A president Don Spencer.

The Oklahoma Attorney General is responsible for defending Oklahoma laws. The AG’s office told the court in a written filing that the challenge to the wording of the petition would be moot if there were not enough signatures to put the law to a statewide vote. “If the Respondents did not submit a sufficient number of signatures to the Secretary of State, the Attorney General believes that this case will be moot and should be dismissed,” Oklahoma Solicitor General Mithun Mansinghani told the court. The court asked the petition sponsors for two things. First, they wanted to know how many people signed the petition. And second, they wanted a response to the protest against the petition.

An attorney for the petition sponsors responded that they gathered between 30,000 and 50,000 signatures, which was far less than the over 59,000 signatures needed to qualify the question for the ballot. It has been reported that the specific signature count was about 37,000, but the number of valid signatures from registered voters was probably much less.

The lawsuit is still pending, but on October 30, Oklahoma County District Judge Don Andrews denied the plaintiffs request for a preliminary injunction that would have prevented the constitutional carry law from going into effect on November 1. Attorney General Mike Hunter released the following statement after the judges ruling: “We are pleased Judge Andrews ruled in our favor and did not grant a preliminary injunction, which will allow this law to go into effect on Nov. 1. My office is proud to defend the constitutional carry law against a political attack by plaintiffs who were unable to succeed at the legislature, unable to persuade voters in the referendum process and now seeking to overturn a duly enacted law with meritless claims and scare tactics.”

With the failure of the veto referendum petition, and if the lawsuit also fails, there is another option that may be attempted by gun control advocates. A initiative petition to place a measure on the ballot to repeal the new law could be undertaken.

Other Stories From Fall 2019 Issue

From the General Manager

Ron McWhirter
For those who dont know me, I am the General Manager of the Oklahoma Constitution newspaper. ...

Note to Legislators: The Conservative Index is Not For You

Steve Byas
Recently, at a meeting of the Oklahoma Conservative Political Action Committee (OCPAC), some...

Congress can overturn Roe v. Wade. Heres how.

Steve M. Antosh
Earlier this year, Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) and Congressman Alex Mooney (R-WV) reintroduced the Life...

School Teachers Begging for Basics

Byron Schlomach
What if a hospitals administrators regularly told surgeons to make do without bandages, with dull...

Be Present at the Death Camp

John Michener
A high place of child sacrifice is located at the intersection of Southwest 44th Street and South...

Trump Is Right, OK Delegation Wrong On Syria

Tim Bakamjian
When Will They Ever Learn?, sang the folk group Peter, Paul and Mary more than 50 years ago in...

Negotiating for Control of Oklahoma

Charlie Meadows
Gov. Kevin Stitt has declared the need to negotiate a more favorable deal for state government with...

The First of the Best Guides to Understanding the Constitution

Bill Graves
In the teaching of the U.S. Constitution, should a law professor direct his students to any...

Should Oklahoma implement Mental Health Testing and Treatment plans in schools?

Linda Murphy
Oklahoma and many other states across the nation are poised to pass legislation and policies...

The Federal Page for Fall 2019

Constitution Staff
The 2020 Clown CarThe 2020 models are now on the showroom floor filled to capacity with funny ...

From the General Manager

Ron McWhirter
On August 6, I was present at the Oklahoma Capitol to witness the ceremonial signing of bills into...

Tidbits for Fall 2019

Constitution Staff
New Oklahoma Cherokee CongresswomanChuck Hoskin Jr., the new Principal Chief of the Cherokee ...

Letters to Editor for Fall 2019

Constitution Staff
False World End PredictionsIt seems like the loud, false, and ignorant claims emanating from t...

Oklahoma Opioid Case Sets Dangerous Precedent

Constitution Staff
The August ruling by Cleveland County Judge Thad Balkman, finding for the state of Oklahoma,...

Signatures Submitted for Medicaid Expansion Initiative Petition

Constitution Staff
On October 24, more than 313,000 signatures were submitted by the Yes on 802 campaign, taking them...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Oklahoma Presidential Primary Election
Oklahoma was among14 states holding Presidential Primary Elections on March 3, 2020 in what is known...

Constitution Staff

Statewide Races and Congressional Seats on Ballot
In 2020, the Oklahoma candidate filing period was April 8-10. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, ...

Constitution Staff

Republicans Will Retain Control of Legislature
The candidate filing period for the Oklahoma Legislature this year was April 8-10. Due to the COVID...

Constitution Staff

Legislature Considers Bills
The Oklahoma Legislature went into its annual mid-session recess on March 18, which coincides with...

Constitution Staff

Gov. Stitt Unveils Plan to Reopen Oklahoma
On April 22, Gov. Kevin Stitt announced the Open Up and Recover Safely (OURS) plan to start...

Constitution Columnists

Ron McWhirter

Covid-19 Impacts the 2020 Oklahoma Conservative Index
We believe the most important product of this publication is our annual Oklahoma Conservative Index...

Steve Byas

Jim Inhofe
Perhaps another person could take his place and do an even better job than Jim Inhofe, but I...

Linda Murphy

Oklahoma Education, Covid and Global Control
Since Spring Break, the public schools have been closed due to COVID 19, bringing children and their...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.