Conservative Index Add

Saturday, June 6th, 2020Last Update: Wednesday, May 6th, 2020 02:21:47 PM

All Judges Survive Retention Ballot

By: Constitution Staff

On November 6, Oklahoma voters retained four Supreme Court justices, three Court of Criminal Appeals judges, and five Court of Civil Appeals judges on the statewide judicial retention ballot. All received more than 50 percent of the vote. In the over 50 years that this system has been in effect, no judge has ever lost a retention ballot election. The Oklahoma Supreme Court is made up of nine justices. The Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals has five justices. The Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals has 12 judges. Unlike district judges and other judges in the state who are elected, these 26 higher court judges are appointed by the governor from a list chosen by the state Judicial Nominating Commission (JNC). This 15 member board includes six members appointed by the governor, six selected by the Oklahoma Bar Association, one named by the Speaker of the House, and one by the Senate Pro Tempore. The final slot is selected at large by the commission members themselves. Commission members serve six-year terms, staggered at two-year intervals. Members-at-large serve for terms of two years. No member is eligible to serve immediately after completing a term on the commission.

The argument for this system is that this group can closely examine the judicial qualifications of the applicants better than the general public. After screening and interviewing applicants, the commission recommends three candidates for the governor to choose from to fill vacant positions on the higher courts and also some vacancies when they occur on the lower courts. If the governor does not like any of the nominees, the governor can only ask the commission to submit a new list of nominees. While the judges are appointed for life, the judges of each court must stand for reelection on six-year terms, which are staggered so that some portion of the state’s appellate judges face retention in every even-numbered year. Because their elections are not competitive, Oklahoma’s Code of Judicial Conduct does not allow appellate judges to raise campaign funds or establish campaign committees to support their retention.

When the Oklahoma Constitution was adopted in 1907, all judges were chosen through partisan elections. Then, in 1965, a bribery scandal involving three Oklahoma Supreme Court justices was revealed. In 1967, these justices were impeached, or resigned from office, after investigations determined the justices had accepted bribes in exchange for making favorable decisions in cases.

In 1940, Missouri was the first state to adopt the assisted appointment method and it has since been known as the “Missouri Plan.” Oklahoma became the seventh state to adopt the Missouri Plan which was being pushed by progressives in both major political parties, the League of Women Voters, and the American Bar Association. On July 11, 1967, Oklahoma voters approved State Question 447 in the primary election by a narrow margin. This ballot measure amended the Oklahoma Constitution by adding Article 7B which established the current system. In 1987, the process was expanded to include the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals. And, in 2010 changes were made concerning the membership of the commission.

Most voters have paid little attention to the Oklahoma Supreme Court (not surprising since they have no say on who gets on it), but in recent years, the liberal slant of this court has become more obvious, with some of their recent decisions. For example, the court voted to throw out an initiative petition to overturn the largest tax increase in state history, and not allow the voters to make a decision on it. They did not like the language of the petition. James Edmondson, Yvonne Kauger, and Noma Gurich have handed down pro-abortion decisions.

Presently, the Oklahoma Supreme Court has nine justices, one of which was chosen by Gov. Frank Keating, two were picked by Gov. Mary Fallin, one selected by Gov. George Nigh, and five were chosen by Gov. Brad Henry. In other words, six of the sitting judges of the Supreme Court were chosen by Democrat governors, with only three picked by Republican governors. Since 1995, while Republicans have held the Governor’s Mansion twice as many years as the Democrats, the Democrats have selected twice as many justices as the Republicans.

Who was up for retention on November 6, and how much of the vote did they receive on the retention ballot? On the Supreme Court, four of the nine justices were up for retention. Justice Yvonne Kauger, 81, was tapped by Gov. Nigh in 1984. She was retained with 62.19 percent of the vote. James E. Edmondson, 73, brother Democrat gubernatorial candidate Drew Edmondson, was appointed by Gov. Henry in 2003. He was retained with 59.4 percent of the vote. Noma D. Gurich, 66, was named by Gov. Henry in 2011 She was retained with 61.57 percent of the vote. Finally, Patrick Wyrick, 37, was appointed by Gov. Fallin in 2017. He was retained with 61.65 percent of the vote. Wyrick is one of the judges President Donald Trump has on his list of 25 potential nominees to the Supreme Court of the United States. He is presently awaiting confirmation to a seat on the U.S. District for the Western District of Oklahoma, located in Oklahoma City.

The Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals is the highest court in Oklahoma for criminal cases, and three of the five justices were up for retention. David B. Lewis was chosen by Gov. Henry in 2005. He was retained with 61.78 percent of the vote. Dana Kuehn and Scott Rowland were both appointed by Gov. Fallin in 2017. Kuehn was retained with 64.32 and Rowland was retained with 62.34 percent.

On the Court of Civil Appeals, which hears appeals from district courts in civil cases, five of its twelve justices are up for retention. Kenneth Buettner was appointed by Gov. Keating in 1996. He was retained with 62.5 percent of the vote. E. Bay Mitchell was a selection of Gov. Keating in 2002. He was retained with 62.13 percent of the vote. Robert “Bobby” Bell was put on the court by Henry in 2005. He was retained with 61.56 percent of the vote. Judge Brian Jack Goree was appointed by Gov. Fallin in 2012. He was retained with 60.93 percent of the vote. Finally, Barbara Green Swinton was a selection of Gov. Fallin in 2016. She was retained with 64.47 percent of the vote

A conservative could have decided to retain the Republican nominees, on the assumption they are more conservative (perhaps a debatable proposition), and vote against the retention of all the judges who were put onto the bench by a Democrat, on the assumption that they are not conservative (a pretty safe assumption). A better choice for the future would be to replace the present system with one in which the voters choose the judges at the ballot box, or at least via gubernatorial appointment and Senate confirmation.

Other Stories From Winter 2019 Issue

A Tale of Two Professors

David Deming
In the Fall 2018 issue of the Oklahoma Constitution, I related the persecution of OU law professor...

Stopping the Revolving Door

Jason Murphey
It was quite the surreal moment in the Oklahoma House of Representatives! As the 2018 legislative...

How I Got In. How I Left.

Julie Wilkinson
Back in 1984, left a dysfunctional relationship with my boyfriend in Florida, and decided to move...

Legislature: Rescind the Con-Con Call

Steve Byas
Legislature: Rescind the Con-Con Call...

Career Politician

Steve Byas
Far too often, political campaigns discuss matters that are really not all that important. Rather...

The Medicaid Mess and How to Deal with it

Tim Bakamjian
Medicaid is a means-tested entitlement program that is overseen by the federal government, but is...

The Federal Page for Winter 2019

Theodore King
Congresswoman Kendra HornI suppose I should offer congratulations to Congreswoman Kendra Horn ...

Abolition Making Victims into Criminals

Richard Engle
In the recent GOP gubernatorial primary a premature retiree from the State House, Dan Fisher, ran a...

Oklahoma Education and Workforce Development

Linda Murphy
Oklahoma state government is in transition to new leadership with Gov. Kevin Stitt, Lt. Gov. Matt...

Why Kill Bills?

John Michener
Grassroots activists around the state support bills based on principle. We believe there is a right...

What Is Wrong With Our Media?

Charlie Meadows
This article will evaluate TV, local talk radio and the Oklahoman regarding the quality of...

Tidbits for Winter 2019

Constitution Staff
Record Voter Registration and TurnoutOfficial voter registration statistics released January ...

Letters to the Editor for Winter 2019

Constitution Staff
Misguided SympathiesLate in 2018 it was announced that here in Oklahoma that one of the State ...

Oklahoma Gross Receipts Finish Strong in 2018

Constitution Staff
Gross Receipts to the state Treasury grew at a double-digit pace, increasing by more than $1.5...

Forty Years of the Oklahoma Constitution

Constitution Staff
With this issue of the Oklahoma Constitution, we celebrate our 40th year of publication. We wish to...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Oklahoma Presidential Primary Election
Oklahoma was among14 states holding Presidential Primary Elections on March 3, 2020 in what is known...

Constitution Staff

Statewide Races and Congressional Seats on Ballot
In 2020, the Oklahoma candidate filing period was April 8-10. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, ...

Constitution Staff

Republicans Will Retain Control of Legislature
The candidate filing period for the Oklahoma Legislature this year was April 8-10. Due to the COVID...

Constitution Staff

Legislature Considers Bills
The Oklahoma Legislature went into its annual mid-session recess on March 18, which coincides with...

Constitution Staff

Gov. Stitt Unveils Plan to Reopen Oklahoma
On April 22, Gov. Kevin Stitt announced the Open Up and Recover Safely (OURS) plan to start...

Constitution Columnists

Ron McWhirter

Covid-19 Impacts the 2020 Oklahoma Conservative Index
We believe the most important product of this publication is our annual Oklahoma Conservative Index...

Steve Byas

Jim Inhofe
Perhaps another person could take his place and do an even better job than Jim Inhofe, but I...

Linda Murphy

Oklahoma Education, Covid and Global Control
Since Spring Break, the public schools have been closed due to COVID 19, bringing children and their...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.