Conservative Index Add

Wednesday, April 8th, 2020Last Update: Tuesday, February 11th, 2020 09:38:01 AM

Oklahoma Opioid Case Sets Dangerous Precedent

By: Constitution Staff

The August ruling by Cleveland County Judge Thad Balkman, finding for the state of Oklahoma, resulted in the defendant, Johnson and Johnson (J & J), being ordered to pay the state $572 million for selling opioids. The attorney general, Mike Hunter, argued that the drug maker was responsible for addiction and deaths resulting from the sale of the drugs made by J & J.

For the past several years, there has been a rise in deaths by patients who have used the legal substances to alleviate chronic pain and for other reasons.

With more than 2,000 states and local governments suing J & J and other manufacturers of various opioid products in federal court in Ohio, and another 250 lawsuits filed in state courts, the litigation could have very serious ramifications.

Attorney General Hunter had asked for $17 billion, arguing that J & J should pay that much to “abate” the alleged public nuisance caused by opioid addiction.

Early in the trial, Balkman, a former Republican state representative from Norman, rejected the request of J & J for a jury trial, despite both the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the state of Oklahoma guaranteeing the right to a jury trial in civil cases involving monetary awards. Balkman justified this denial of the right to trial by jury, and simply said he would decide the case himself, reasoning that juries are not needed to abate a nuisance.

This was considered a novel legal interpretation of nuisance torts, usually involving damage to property, with the ordinary remedy being an order to the defendant to stop an action that is considered a nuisance. For a simple example, if someone is dumping garbage on someone’s property, they are told to stop. In this case, however, Judge Balkman opted to both deny Johnson their right to a trial by jury and award monetary damages.

Some cities like New York City have seized upon these public nuisance torts to sue oil companies, clearly stretching the law beyond its intended purpose. What is particularly troubling about this case is that a Republican attorney general argued this novel legal theory and a Republican judge bought this novel legal theory.

As the Wall Street Journal wrote at the time, this constituted nothing more than a “shakedown.”

How did J & J do wrong? The Food and Drug Administration approved the use of the drugs, along with the warnings which accompanied the drugs that opioids are highly addictive and should be used only as prescribed and with great caution. J & J did not mislead any physicians, pharmacies, or patients that their product had no adverse consequences if used in a manner other than prescribed.

As the Wall Street Journal said, “Hunter can’t draw a clear line between doctors who supposedly relied on the opioid companies’ alleged misrepresentations and the injuries suffered by victims. He doesn’t even attempt to specify the particular doctors, prescriptions, pharmacists or victims involved in the chain of addiction.”

Balkman even allowed testimony by the father of a former OU football player who overdosed on opioids and other medications to relieve his intense pain. But no evidence was presented that the former player had even used any products of J & J.

The danger of cases such as this is that no evidence is needed to demonstrate any direct causation.

Under the dubious reasoning of Hunter, which Balkman apparently accepted, anyone selling a legal product could be held liable if the purchaser used the product in a manner not intended by the manufacturer. The family of a suicide victim could sue a gun manufacturer. The family of a person killed by a drunk driver could sue the company that made the liquor. In these and other similar cases, a gun, alcohol, an automobile, and so on, could be considered to be perpetrating a “nuisance,” and be stripped of their constitutional rights.

“By this standard, cell manufacturers could be liable for damages caused by distracted drivers,” the Wall Street Journal explained.

In addition to the potentially devastating effects that such liberal rulings could have on legitimate businesses, the decision will only add to the suffering of many with chronic pain, thousands of which use these products as J & J intended them to be used.

Some from the local chapter of Don’t Punish Pain, a group that represents for access to opioids and other pain medication for individuals suffering from chronic pain, were present. Brenda Allen from Moore was there to protest for her daughter, Jennifer, who suffers from chronic pain. According to the Norman Transcript, Allen said, “She was being helped greatly by the pain medications and enabled her to work, take care of her kids, go to church ... just have a life. When the CDC came out with [opioid prescribing guidelines in March of 2016] and all the doctors started reducing pain medications, her pain went up, her blood pressure skyrocketed, and she is pretty much bed-bound now.”

Another protester has suffered chronic pain since being hit by a drunk driver in 1982.

While some were gleeful at the decision, simply because they do not like big drug companies, the damage to our system of private enterprise is potentially enormous – and there will be hundreds of thousands of patients who will suffer additional physical pain because of this ruling.

J & J is appealing the decision. Hopefully, we still have some appellate court judges who will uphold the state Constitution and throw this decision in the trash.

Other Stories From Fall 2019 Issue

From the General Manager

Ron McWhirter
For those who dont know me, I am the General Manager of the Oklahoma Constitution newspaper. ...

Note to Legislators: The Conservative Index is Not For You

Steve Byas
Recently, at a meeting of the Oklahoma Conservative Political Action Committee (OCPAC), some...

Congress can overturn Roe v. Wade. Heres how.

Steve M. Antosh
Earlier this year, Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) and Congressman Alex Mooney (R-WV) reintroduced the Life...

School Teachers Begging for Basics

Byron Schlomach
What if a hospitals administrators regularly told surgeons to make do without bandages, with dull...

Be Present at the Death Camp

John Michener
A high place of child sacrifice is located at the intersection of Southwest 44th Street and South...

Trump Is Right, OK Delegation Wrong On Syria

Tim Bakamjian
When Will They Ever Learn?, sang the folk group Peter, Paul and Mary more than 50 years ago in...

Negotiating for Control of Oklahoma

Charlie Meadows
Gov. Kevin Stitt has declared the need to negotiate a more favorable deal for state government with...

The First of the Best Guides to Understanding the Constitution

Bill Graves
In the teaching of the U.S. Constitution, should a law professor direct his students to any...

Should Oklahoma implement Mental Health Testing and Treatment plans in schools?

Linda Murphy
Oklahoma and many other states across the nation are poised to pass legislation and policies...

The Federal Page for Fall 2019

Constitution Staff
The 2020 Clown CarThe 2020 models are now on the showroom floor filled to capacity with funny ...

From the General Manager

Ron McWhirter
On August 6, I was present at the Oklahoma Capitol to witness the ceremonial signing of bills into...

Tidbits for Fall 2019

Constitution Staff
New Oklahoma Cherokee CongresswomanChuck Hoskin Jr., the new Principal Chief of the Cherokee ...

Letters to Editor for Fall 2019

Constitution Staff
False World End PredictionsIt seems like the loud, false, and ignorant claims emanating from t...

Oklahoma Opioid Case Sets Dangerous Precedent

Constitution Staff
The August ruling by Cleveland County Judge Thad Balkman, finding for the state of Oklahoma,...

Signatures Submitted for Medicaid Expansion Initiative Petition

Constitution Staff
On October 24, more than 313,000 signatures were submitted by the Yes on 802 campaign, taking them...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Gross Receipts Indicate Economic Expansion Slowing
Oklahoma Gross Receipts to the Treasury for calendar year 2019 paint the picture of a sound, but...

Constitution Staff

Status of Petitions Filed to Place State Questions on Ballot
A numbers of petitions to secure a place on the Oklahoma ballot in 2020 have been filed with the...

Constitution Staff

Oklahoma Presidential Primary Election
Oklahoma is among 14 states holding Presidential Primary Elections on March 3, 2020 in what is known...

Constitution Staff

Legislature Completes Bill Filing
On January 16, the two chambers of the Oklahoma Legislature completed bill filing for the second...

Constitution Columnists

John Michener

Equal Justice Demands passage of the Abolition of Abortion in Oklahoma Act
The natural law of God which says that we shall not murder innocent human beings transcends...

Bill Graves

Judge Balkman Right in Not Ordering a Jury Trial In Opioid Case
The Oklahoma Constitution newspaper in its Fall, 2019 edition took Judge Thad Balkman to task for a...

Shane Smith

Oklahomans Deserve the Full Story Surrounding Vaccine Safety and Effectiveness
Oklahomans Deserve the Full Story Surrounding Vaccine Safety and EffectivenessThere are serious...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.