Conservative Index Add
pagetitle

Sunday, September 23rd, 2018Last Update: Tuesday, July 31st, 2018 11:05:57 AM

Big Government Groundhog Day

By: Rep. Jason Murphey

State officials are continuing to consider an array of tax and fee increases. I instinctively know that these taxes and fees will have a traumatic effect on the state’s economy and I will oppose them.

When the government increases a fee or tax it discourages the public from doing business and ironically this can result in an actual decrease in state government revenues.

Those who want to raises taxes and fees are reviewing the tax spreadsheets and scrounging for more revenues. They look at their spreadsheet and do some very basic math such as: “this fee generates 3 million dollars each year, if we increase the fee by 50% it will generate an extra 1.5 million.”

Over the years I have observed that once the tax-increasing state official does this math, it can be very hard to diffuse him of the notion that his logic is flawed.

I can explain, “just because you raise the fee doesn’t mean you will get that much revenue because you will put some people out of business and then they won’t be around to give you any money at all. You might actually see a revenue drop because of this.”

My logic isn’t well received. It’s easier for the tax increasor to believe his simplistic math than the intangible theories of what they perceive to be a free market ideologue.

However, this year is different. I have the benefit of very tangible results to make my case.

In April, state legislators won committee approval for a punitive and massive new fee on the vending machine industry. They proposed a 200 percent increase on the yearly fee for each vending machine’s decal – from 75 dollars per machine to 150 per machine.

Those who have read these articles from previous years will know that this is “groundhog day” as this isn’t the first time this has been enacted.

In 2010, as the state dealt with a large budget shortfall, they made a very similar mistake. They increased the fee on the vending machines by 300%. In 2010, soon after passage of the fee increase, I wrote the following:

“This new law will have a devastating impact on Oklahoma’s vending machine operators, at least one of whom lives in House District 31. He has since informed me that he has already pulled his first machine out of service and may very well go out of business.”

Small business owners are not the only ones affected. Legislators have been informed by Coca-Cola that the change will also impact their business. They may be forced to pull marginally producing machines and lay off employees as a result.

This reduction in the number of machines will reduce the revenue which the fee generates to the state. Ironically, legislators will be in part thwarted in the effort to generate revenue because there will probably be fewer machines to tax. And, as a result of this short-sighted policy, any number of Oklahomans may become unemployed.”

Unfortunately, I was in the minority opinion and the majority of the Legislature voted for the increase.

About Rep. Jason Murphey

State Representative Jason Murphey (R-Guthrie) represents House District 31. He is Chairman of the Government Modernization Committee. He may be reached via e-mail at: Jason.Murphey@hd31.org

Other Articles By Rep. Jason Murphey

My Criteria for Voting on Legislative Proposals

Consider the following statement one might hear if they stay around the capitol very long: If...

The Need to Transform the Legislative Process

It is the time of year when legislators file legislation for the next session. Every so often I feel...

The New Ideology of the Legislature

I will detail here the chain of events that transformed what I initially believed could be the best...

Big Government Groundhog Day

State officials are continuing to consider an array of tax and fee increases. I instinctively know...

No to Gas Tax Increase

You may have recently seen news stories describing the impending introduction of a gas tax increase....

Giving Away Absolute Power For One Year

Many taxpayers believe the Legislature operates as described in American Government class. They...

Vote Walking

Each year, members of the Legislature cast votes impacting almost every aspect of life: from public...

Other Constitution Columnists

Brandon Dutcher

What Type of School Would Oklahomans Select?
Leaders in the public-education community often point out (correctly) that the vast majority of...

Richard Engle

A Few Modest Proposals
As candidates for office, from statewide to state house, search for votes, they might want an idea...

Andrew K. Boyle

Oklahoma Pot in a Nation of Nazis
Polemic prose concerning political discourse abounds at present, in the most bizarre terms. It plays...

John Michener

Primary Election Analysis: What Happened? What Does It Mean?
What can we take away from the primary elections held on June 26? Broadly speaking, we see that...

Theodore King

THE FEDERAL PAGE FOR SUMMER 2018
The First District RaceOn Monday, June 18, I attended a seminar in Tulsa on crypto-currencies, i.e....

David Deming

OU President Galloglys Challenge
When he assumed office on July 1, OU President James Gallogly found a full plate. But foremost among...

Steve Byas

Is Ignorance Now a Virtue from Candidates for Public Office?
With Tulsa-area businessman Kevin Stitt making the runoff for governor, I am now persuaded that a...

In The News

Constitution Staff

Races for Congress
The U.S. Congress is composed of two chambers. Senators serve six-year terms with only a third of...

Constitution Staff

Statewide Secondary Offices
In addition to the governors office, a host of secondary statewide offices, and one seat for the...

Constitution Staff

Race for Governor Continues
Mary Fallin was prohibited by term-limits from seeking a third four-year term in 2018. With the seat...

Constitution Staff

Medical Marijuana Approved by Voters
There was only one state question on the June 26 primary election ballot, and it was approved by...

Constitution Staff

Oklahoma State Legislators Rated
The Oklahoma Constitution presents the 40th annual Oklahoma Conservative Index, rating our state...

Constitution Columnists

Brandon Dutcher

What Type of School Would Oklahomans Select?
Leaders in the public-education community often point out (correctly) that the vast majority of...

Richard Engle

A Few Modest Proposals
As candidates for office, from statewide to state house, search for votes, they might want an idea...

Andrew K. Boyle

Oklahoma Pot in a Nation of Nazis
Polemic prose concerning political discourse abounds at present, in the most bizarre terms. It plays...

© 2001 - 2009 The Oklahoma Constitution, all rights reserved.
Contact the Oklahoma Constitution by calling 405-366-1125 or emailing okconsti@aol.com
Content Management System (CMS) provided by WebTeks CMS.